Home / Beard / Beard Balm vs Beard Butter: Differences Explained

Beard Balm vs Beard Butter: Differences Explained

by  Kin Liu -  Last updated on January 20, 2022
guy with a beard

Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links. This means that at no cost to you, we may earn a small commission for qualifying purchases.

A great beard needs great care; healthy, shiny, groomed facial hair doesn’t just happen. That’s why every beard-sporter should have at least one go-to product to moisturize and style their facial locks. Beard grooming can be a very tedious task.

But you may have noticed that the market is flooded with all sorts of different products for beard grooming, in particular beard balms and beard butters. And one of the most common questions among beard-wearers today is ‘What the heck is the difference?’

Well there actually is a difference between a beard balm and beard butter. And although these differences can be subtle, you want to make sure you are using the right product for your needs.

Take a look below for a rundown of the differences and to find out which product you should be using!

Beard Balm Vs Beard Butter at a Glance

If you don’t want to read the whole article, check out our recommended beard balm and beard butter in the table below.

Beard Balm

  • Thick, waxy texture
  • Strong styling power
  • Light conditioning
  • ideal for medium and long beards

Beard Butter

  • Creamy texture
  • Light styling power
  • Deep conditioning
  • Can be used daily on short, medium and long beards

Recommended Beard Balms

Heavy Duty Beard Balm by Honest Amish

Honest Amish - Heavy Duty Beard Balm - 2 Ounce - Beard Conditioner
  • Hand Crafted in the USA
  • Softens and Conditions, Tames Unruly Beard Hairs
  • All Natural and Organic Ingredients

This heavy duty beard balm by Amish is ideal for softening and conditioning coarse beards. It has a soothing fragrance and made from organic butter like shea butter and natural oils or essential oils. The coolest thing is that its free from harmful chemicals and artificial colors. If you want to learn more about the product, check out our brief review article on Honest Amish Beard Balm. One of the finest beard care products out there and is perfect to keep your beard routine in check. This is one of the great products when it comes to beard balm.

Beard Balm by Rocky Mountain Barber

Beard Balm - Rocky Mountain Barber - 100% Natural - Premium Wax Blend with Cedarwood Scent, Nutrient Rich Bees Wax, Jojoba, Tea Tree, Coconut Oil
  • Cedarwood Scent - Our Cedarwood beard balm features real cedarwood essential oil for its signature cedarwood scent.
  • Convenient 2 oz tin - Our Cedarwood beard balm comes to you in a rugged 2 oz tin and fits anywhere for on the go grooming.
  • Simple Ingredients - Our Cedarwood beard balm features simple ingredients so you can feel good about what you’re using on your beard.

Rocky Mountain Barber Beard Balm comes with a pleasant cedarwood fragrance and works well with all kinds of beards. It contains essential minerals, shea butter, fatty acids, and vitamins that supplement beard growth and nourish your hair alike. One of the finest beard care products out there.

Recommended Beard Butter

Live Bearded Beard Butter

Live Bearded: Beard Butter, Made in USA - American, 3oz - Beard Leave in Conditioner- Beard Care to Moisturize, Style, Condition - Beard Softener with Shea Butter & All-Natural Ingredients
  • BEARD PERFECTION WITH ALL-NATURAL INGREDIENTS: Not just for the suit-and-tie beardsman. Our beard butter is for anyone who takes charge of their life and wants optimal beard growth, which requires real ingredients that not only moisturize, but are also genuinely good for your skin and beard hair.
  • MOISTURIZE, STYLE AND CONDITION: This beard moisturizer for men offers a light/medium hold, while locking in deep moisture, controlling flyaway hairs, and keeping your beard styled without weighing it down or feeling greasy.
  • COMPLETE YOUR BEARD GROWTH KIT: Combine our Beard Butter with our Beard Wash, Beard Oil, Boar’s Hair Beard Brush, and other products so you can grow to your full potential.

This beard butter is sold by Live Bearded brand and comes in three versions: American, Wingman, and Straight Up. It is great for softening dry beards and promotes better beard growth by making the hair grow fully works exactly like beard oil. One of the finest beard care products out there and will keep your beard nice and soft.

Beard Guyz Beard Butter

Beard Guyz Beard Butter - for Your Dry Beard (4 oz)
  • LEAVE IN NATURAL CONDITIONER WITHOUT THE GREASY LOOK— Transforms a dry, unruly beard while relieving itchiness. Our exclusive formula includes Shea and Mango butters and Coconut Oil. Applies evenly, absorbs naturally, and softens the beard for a natural look
  • GREAT FOR DRY & ITCHY SKIN—Our customers have told us that after trying many different beard butters, ours was the best because it kept the flakes to a minimum and left their beards soft and shiny without a greasy feeling
  • THE PERFECT LIGHTWEIGHT TEXTURE AND CONSISTENCY FOR YOUR BEARD—Our Beard Butter keeps your beard conditioned, balanced, and soft. It can be easily spread throughout the beard with no problem

Beard Guyz made this lightweight and non-greasy beard butter from shea butter, mango, cocoa butter, and coconut oil. It is similar to any beard oil out there and is an excellent product for hydrating and softening dry, itchy beard, and comes with a customer satisfaction guarantee.

We feel this is one of the finest beard care products out there and is perfect to keep your beard routine in check. This is one of the great products when it comes to beard butter.

Should I use beard Balm or beard Butter?

Do you want to style your beard?

If you like to style your beard, or have a particularly long or scraggly beard that needs some help keeping its shape, you might prefer a beard balm. If you are looking for a more natural look, preferring to lightly style your beard and leave it with a healthy, soft finish check out a beard butter which is the perfect alternative for beard oil.

Is your beard dry and damaged?

If you have a very dry, damaged beard that is in need of some intense moisture, use a beard butter. This helps to deep-condition daily and keep your hair in healthy shape. If you prefer a light, moisturizing effect, a beard balm may suit you better.

Do you want an all-in-one product?

If you prefer to use just one product and prefer a more low maintenance routine, we recommend going for a beard butter. The moisturizing properties nourish any type of hair and skin, leaving it looking and feeling soft and shiny.

It lightly shapes and styles while deeply conditioning at the same time. With a beard balm however, you may need to use another product every now and again to deeply moisturize the hair. You can also use beard oil, it is an excellent beard butter alternative as a beard oil addresses the same problem that beard butter addresses.

What’s the Difference Between Them?

Texture and Ingredients

The difference between a beard balm and beard butter is that Beard balms are usually thicker and waxier than beard butter. They are usually made with Beeswax and other carrier oils and have tacky texture. Beard balms mostly come in a solid form in a small metal tin or pot.

The stiff texture helps to really shape, style and hold your beard as well as hydrating it. To use a beard balm, take a small amount of balm on your hand and rub it between your fingers where the texture will turn thick and oily.

Then rub this through your beard thoroughly and evenly to style and smooth! All-natural ingredients will help to nourish and not dry out your beard. Many are scented with essential oils. Beard butters, on the other hand, have a lighter, whipped and creamier texture.

They are usually made with nourishing natural butters such as Shea Butter, Cocoa Butter etc. as well as other carrier oils. This means they are specially designed to deeply nourish and condition the beard, and provide a more natural and less styled look.

The butter can be scooped into the hand and rubbed between the fingers where it will take on a smooth, oily consistency and rubbed through the beard.

Styling power

If you are looking for a product to style your beard and hold every hair in place all day long, beard balm is a must. It works a bit like a hair gel, with strong fixing properties that will smooth out stray hairs and add life and shape to your beard.

Unruly beards, particularly medium or long ones, may particularly benefit from the taming and grooming properties of a beard balm. Careful that you use a product that works for you and don’t add too much, as this could leave your beard feeling stiff or hardened.

If you prefer a lighter, more natural look and a less-styled beard, a beard butter could be for you. It helps to keep your beard looking healthy and soft, as well as lightly adding shape and styling away unruly hairs. However it doesn’t offer the same level of hold as a beard balm.

This makes it great for people who prefer a natural look and are more about deep conditioning and soft, healthy facial hair instead.

Moisturizing power

A beard balm has some moisturizing qualities as it is usually made with carrier oils or butter that nourish and hydrate the hair. The moisturizing power of a balm, however, is much less than that of a beard butter but it will stimulate a healthy beard and quality beard growth.

Balm may be ideal for people who are looking to style and shape while lightly moisturizing at the same time. Rather than those with parched, damaged beards in need of deep conditioning.

If you are in search of a product to deep condition a dry or scraggly beard, try a beard butter. It intensely moisturizes the hair to leave it looking healthy, soft and shiny.

Commonly included ingredients are natural butters like Shea Butter. They absorb quickly into the beard, instantly giving your beard a fuller, healthier texture. The moisturizing properties of beard butters also help to encourage hair growth.

A great thing about beard butters is that they also absorb into the face behind your beard, helping to hydrate dry, scratchy skin and reduce ‘beardruff’.

Beard type and use

A beard balm can often be better suited to a medium to long beard. This is because a scraggly or unruly beard may need some more heavy duty help. Beard balms are versatile however, and can be used up to twice daily!

A beard butter can be well suited to all types of beard. The moisturizing properties nourish any type of hair and skin, leaving it looking and feeling soft and shiny. A beard butter can also be used daily.

The verdict?

While both balms and butter can be great depending on the look you want to achieve and the state of your beard, overall our winner is… beard butter!

It is a great all-in-one product that both moisturizes and styles but leaves you with a natural, healthy look! And it is low maintenance, just throw it on after showering daily and you are good to go!

Related Buying Guides:

Last update on 2024-04-22 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Comments are closed.